
David Fincher’s The Curious Case of Benjamin Button is a slightly bloated visual effects extravaganza of awesomeness. David Fincher weaves a somewhat simple narrative through the course of the main character’s journey, but does it in a way that is surprisingly satisfactory. Fincher shows again that he’s a master, but unfortunately doesn’t learn from the mistakes of Zodiac. His previous film, Zodiac, a suspense thriller chronicleing the murders by the serial killer of the same monicker, was not received well critically due it’s drawn out running time. Button suffers from the same problem.
I have enjoyed all of Fincher’s movies (besides Panic Room. that shit was awful.) and this was among the best. It’s no fight club, but comparing it to arguably the greatest movie of our generation is a tough feat for any film.
Brad Pitt’s performance was adequite. It’s Brad Pitt. He kinda only does one thing; stand there and look pretty. Oh, and he did a lot of that. I was a little taken aback by how good Fincher actually made him look. The special effects are astounding. Not in an, “oh, my god! Godzilla is destroying tokyo” way either. They’re way more subtle than the trailers actually put forth. Well, not subtle per say, but they serve the story instead of becoming an attraction unto themselves.
Now, on to the bad stuff:
The movie needs a face-lift. BAD. The opening and ending scenes need to go. Completely. Almost every sequence needs to be punched up, thinned out, or nixed completely. The necessity of the editing does not necessarily lie in the pace or flow of the movie, it’s in the overall running time. The movie gets bogged down early on and in the last act focused on details that could be skimmed over in favor of a grander picture.
Hopefully, David Fincher will keep this level of quality, and just make shorter movies. I look forward to his future adaptation of Eric Powell’s The Goon.
Posted under dave's blog